Negotiation Information

The Six Rs for Changing MInds and Overcoming Resistance


This article borrows from Howard Gardner's book, "Changing Minds" (2004). In order to get people in conflict to cooperate or collaborate sufficiently to settle or resolve their differences, and perhaps achieve reconciliation, it is necessary that they change their minds. The reason they are in dispute is because they are of two different minds about a particular thing, which is what they are fighting over. People do not change their minds easily. Some people are prepared to be burned at the stake, literally, rather than change their minds, or admit to a change of belief. People cling to the artifacts of their own minds with great stubbornness. This is called resistance. When a mediator seeks to bring parties together, she will encounter resistance. If there were no resistance, if changing minds was easy, there would be no need for mediators.

Howard Gardner has identified six R's, which are helpful in helping people to change their minds. They are: reason, research, resonance, re-description, rewards and real world events.

Reason is employed by way of the use of argument in order to persuade.

Research is used in order to collect facts, also with the purpose of persuading, often a mediation is a conflict between competing facts.

Resonance appeals to the feeling part of the human personality. Does a proposal feel right? Some people rely heavily upon resonance, and prefer it to a reasoned and researched position. Orators and advertisers seek a message that will resonate their audience.

Re-description can be profoundly effective. Matters are often expressed in the negative, but when changed into a positive form of expression, convey a completely different and more attractive meaning. Mediations are often a persistent attempt to re-describe the problem in order to make solutions seem more attractive.

Rewards are an important part of any negotiation, and are usually accompanied by penalties. This is often known as the "stick and carrot" approach.

Real world events can have the effect of changing parties' perceptions completely. Such events may be quite trivial, like going out for lunch. After lunch, what was said in the morning and rejected out of hand may, with the benefit of the simple event of several hours passing and a meal, seem much more attractive.

The ever-present problem of the mediator is that parties do not want to budge, but unless there is some change they start to get impatient. So the job of the mediator is to continue to make some progress, so that there is a perception of movement. This is necessary in order to keep the parties at the negotiating table. So it is helpful to the mediator to be able to play upon the six R's, developing a facility with each one, in order to keep the parties going through the process in a productive way. Ultimately, the matter must be resolved, not by the mediator but by the parties themselves. The combined focused attention of their minds is what will accomplish the result that they have come to mediation to achieve. The mediator, by using the six R's, helps to maintain the process to its successful conclusion.

Charles B. Parselle is a mediator, arbitrator and attorney. He graduated from Oxford University's Honor School of Jurisprudence and is a member of the English bar, then was admitted to the California Bar in 1983. A practicing attorney, he is a prolific author and sought-after mediator. To consult him, please contact him through his website: http://www.parsellemediation.com


MORE RESOURCES:

The Associated Press

US calls on Iran to choose nuclear negotiation
The Associated Press - 10 hours ago
GENEVA (AP) — The United States is calling on Iran to negotiate over its nuclear program, after diplomats agreed to resume talks in two weeks on suspending ...


ABC News

‘Time horizon’ set for Iraq pullout: US Gen
Pakistan Dawn, Pakistan - 1 hour ago
The accords under negotiation are intended to “establish a normalised bilateral relationship between Iraq and the United States.” In a related development, ...
US, Iraq to set a ‘time horizon’ for withdrawal of combat troops Kansas City Star
US, Iraq seek 'general time horizon' on troop cuts Dallas Morning News
US and Iraq to set "time horizon" on troops EcoDiario.es
Reuters - Minneapolis Star Tribune
all 787 news articles


WELT ONLINE

Bush's U-turn toward common sense
Los Angeles Times, CA - 21 hours ago
In classic diplomatic doublespeak, the Bush administration insists this is not "negotiation" but "pre-negotiation," with Burns as a mere "observer. ...
Flexibility points to Iran breakthrough Asia Times Online
World supports new nuclear talks with Iran PRESS TV
Iran Columnist Analyzes Factors Leading to Nuclear Talks in Geneva RedOrbit
Reuters - Deutsche Welle
all 3,104 news articles


Natives take aim at hotel project
Brantford Expositor, Canada - 12 hours ago
Some Six Nations members have never publicly embraced the route of protest over negotiation. David General, former band council chief, said he's been ...


New York Times

Can world trade talks keep pace with global change?
Tehran Times, Iran - 2 hours ago
And even if ministers agree on the outline of a deal at their marathon meeting, some wonder whether this might be the last negotiation of this kind. ...
Will a global trade treaty hurt more than it helps? Reuters South Africa
Brazil official's Nazi reference rocks WTO talks The Associated Press
Brazil prepared to wait four years for better WTO deal AFP
New Zealand Herald - New York Times
all 418 news articles


White House insists US-Iraq negotiation over forces "on track"
Xinhua, China - Jul 14, 2008
WASHINGTON, July 14 (Xinhua) -- The US-Iraq negotiations over a long-term American military presence remained "on track," White House spokeswoman Dana ...


Agents need to get back to the art of negotiation and personal ...
Seattle Post Intelligencer - Jul 17, 2008
Deals were made and negotiation happened. In this more challenging market, it seems getting back to the personal presentation would be a smart move for both ...


China reiterates dialogue, negotiation over Zimbabwe issue
Xinhua, China - Jul 17, 2008
BEIJING, July 17 (Xinhua) -- The Chinese Foreign Ministry said here on Thursday that it insists political dialogue and negotiation were "the only correct ...


The art of negotiation inspires `Shrew'
Daily Breeze, CA - Jul 18, 2008
For Donenberg, however, the driving force behind this "Taming of the Shrew" is the art of negotiation. And for inspiration, the 51-year-old director says he ...


Central American entrepreneurs call for more progress in trade ...
Xinhua, China - Jul 16, 2008
Representatives of about 50 Central American businesses expressed their grave concerns about the slow development in the negotiation of the Association ...

Negotiation - Google News

home | site map
© 2006