Negotiation Information

Can a Corporate Executive Really Use The Beautiful Mind; To guide decision making?


I would like to comment on the "A Beautiful Mind" movie and the book, which was actually much better. I just finished reading another book on the similar side of John Nashs' assertion of working together rather than competing against. That book was "Co-opetition." By Adam M. Brandenburger (Havard guy)and Barry J. Nalebuff (Yale Dude). Many have been aware of such theory for quite a while and practice such occasionally for the betterment of an industry or through the art of diplomacy, sometimes through misdirection and other times as an experiment (nothing more, nothing less) especially when it really does not matter and it is not really core to our direction and market domination strategy for any given region. I would have to differ from the movie version in that if you tried to run your business in the fashion that Jim Nash discussed in theory you might do well for a while, but would eventually get hammered in the market place, whether or not you actually were able to sleep with a brunette when you wanted the blond with the big bust (go see the movie, you will understand that comment). In theory it sounded wonderful in the movie yet would not take you very far in the cut throat world of business, even though the regulators always want to level the playing field, more often then not they are manipulated agents for the competition as indicated by Adam Smith, Carl Marx and Rodney Dangerfield in "Back to School." The fact is that even the referees of business, namely the regulating bodies who want to see the playing field leveled usually tip it in the favor of a politically powerful and well connected companies which fund the campaigns of the over see'ers (politicians). Once the regulatory bodies find they have been duped rather than bring it up with the politicians, they want to punish all the players in the industry and kick them out of the game, of course this hurts the fans (consumers) and then the game (industry) and then the referees and fans are not needed (read; "When Atlas Shrugged" By Ayn Rand).

Unless a perfect and fair playing field exists John Nash's dream of a perfect system and economic structure cannot exist and that is pretty straight forward with the study of human psychology, Machiavelli, Maslow's hierarchy of needs, the prisoners, dilemma or a multitude of truisms surrounding human nature. The world does not work that way, it is not a perfect world and therefore such theories are not worthy of attempt although obviously interesting from an academia standpoint or discussion at the geological societies random coffee house dialogues.

The win-lose scenario keeps forcing someone to lose, if we were to really see the true picture here we would find that what John Nash was saying is that you need to take into consideration giving someone else what they want so you can get what you want. I say Obviously John is right. Too bad regulators condemn the greatest contributors of mankind, while the competitors cheat, the playing field is not leveled and the true voter of the monetary unit of trade called a dollar cannot see thru the clutter and scatter of the advertising and behind the scenes truisms of a system which is not all it seems.

When looking at the true methodology of John Nash's achievements it is fair to say that being able to put simple concepts into mathematical formulas will significantly help the future of computers capable of fuzzy logic calculate the answers to game theory, war efforts, strategic thinking and competition exposure in business. That will be one of the great achievements of his work, which will be in the future. However one who is at the helm of a business has other responsibilities such as the survival and profitability of the company and using John Nash's strict modeling in an imperfect world is dangerous to the ongoing vitality of a once going concern. Be careful to prematurely adopt perfect systems in an imperfect world.

"Lance Winslow" - If you have innovative thoughts and unique perspectives, come think with Lance; www.WorldThinkTank.net/wttbbs


MORE RESOURCES:

BorderFire Report

Ready for the Great Negotiation? You better be
BorderFire Report, TX - 1 hour ago
He has a great negotiation ahead of him to unite the country. As a negotiation coach working with hundreds of million of dollars in negotiations every day ...


Moneycontrol.com

With IC-814 in memory, India didn’t talk to terrorists
Moneycontrol.com, India - 12 hours ago
“In future incidents, the terrorists know they can succeed by negotiation.” The 1999 negotiation response may have also inspired subsequent terrorism ...


New York Times

Assemblyman slams Yankee Stadium deal
Lower Hudson Journal news, NY - 15 hours ago
"This negotiation was taking place at a time when the Yankees were dramatically raising ticket prices, while the state and the city were giving essentially ...
City demanded free suite, food from Yankees, e-mails reveal New York Daily News
Yankee Suite for Mayor's Office? 1010 Wins
all 14 news articles


BBC News

Negotiation time is over, Mugabe must now be removed
The Zimbabwean, Africa - 17 hours ago
Former US President Jimmy Carter, when he was barred from stepping in Zimbabwe by President Robert Mugabe, wittingly responded: "I think it's the ...
MDC-T playing God in Zim crisis The Sunday Mail
MDC: Zim deal 'unlikely' Mail & Guardian Online
Mugabe impervious to outside pressures The National
SW Radio Africa
all 1,309 news articles


Athletic Business

The Powerful Negotiator
Athletic Business - 17 hours ago
"Negotiation is a crucially important skill for athletic directors," says Dave Mullins, director of athletics at East Tennessee State University. ...


Negotiating skills for IT consultants
TechRepublic, KY - 8 hours ago
Have you ever won over a potential client with a perfect presentation but lost them at the negotiation table? Rick Freedman describes what can go wrong and ...


The Grand Rapids Press - MLive.com

Grand Rapids native shares storied FBI career in new book
The Grand Rapids Press - MLive.com, MI - 3 hours ago
That truism was punctuated when he led the FBI's crisis negotiation team from 1981 to 1995 and was a supervisory member of its international critical ...


ABC News

Apple's negotiation with Beatles put on hold
MacNN, CA - Nov 25, 2008
Paul McCartney has said that the negotiations to bring the Beatles' music onto iTunes have encountered problems, according to the Associated Press. ...
Paul McCartney: Negotiation stalled between Beatles, iTunes AZ Central.com
McCartney reveals further stall in Beatles download discussions musicweek.com
Paul McCartney: Beatles and iTunes negotiations stalled In Entertainment
all 629 news articles


Getting the Best Salary Offer Possible
T+D, VA - 8 hours ago
Know your value, and have your own goals for the negotiation clearly in mind. Go into negotiation knowing your bottom-line requirements, ...


Hossa a Holland Favourite to Stay
Rotoworld.com - Nov 30, 2008
Hossa, Franzen, and Zetterberg's contracts are up for negotiation after this season and Detroit can't keep them all. Sources claim GM Ken Holland wants to ...

Negotiation - Google News

home | site map
© 2006